Elf (Marquis Theatre)

By Harry Forbes

When “Elf” premiered on Broadway back in 2010, I opined that the show was so good it could easily have staying power well beyond the new year. My cheeky advice went unheeded, of course, and the show closed after playing its planned seasonal run. But it was brought back at Christmastime a couple of years later. 

And now, here it is again, this time with a thoroughly new production team, with its essential quality emerging as remembered. 

Polls have repeatedly named the 2003 Will Ferrell film “most popular Christmas movie” so, for most, a synopsis is probably superfluous. But for the uninitiated, “Elf” tells of central character Buddy, who had been brought to an orphanage by his dying mother and subsequently managed to climb into Santa’s sack, so was raised in the North Pole believing himself to be an elf. 

When Santa finally reveals Buddy’s backstory, Buddy travels to New York to meet his birth father, Walter Hobbs, previously unaware of Buddy's existence. Long since remarried to Emily, Walter now has a young son, Charlie, one who doesn’t believe in Santa Claus any more than the work-consumed Walter. When a DNA test verifies Buddy’s parentage, Walter reluctantly takes him in. Eventually, Buddy lands a job in Macy’s Christmas department where he falls for the loveless Jovie. It’s hardly a spoiler to reveal that all is set right eventually with a giant affirmation of Santa Claus. 

Once again, I admired the economy of Thomas Meehan and Bob Martin’s script which satisfyingly honors the film’s screenplay by David Berenbaum. And the tuneful, old-time Broadway score by Matthew Sklar (music) and Chad Beguelin (lyrics) -- under the musical direction of Alan Williams -- is a pleasure to hear again.

Smartly cast with Broadway pros Ashley Brown and Michael Hayden as Charlie’s parents; “Tina” alum Kaylen Davion as Jovie, Jennifer Sánchez as Walter’s good natured secretary Deb, Kai Edgar as Michael, Kalen Allen as a beleaguered Macy’s manager, and Sean Astin skillfully switching between Walter’s bottom-line boss Mr. Greenway and jovial Santa. All are excellent.

Musically, Brown and Edgar knock it out of the park with their two duets, “I’ll Believe in You” and “There is a Santa Claus.” Davion scores with her soulful “Never Fall in Love.” And Sanchez in a particular bright spot in all her moments, musical and otherwise. 

As Buddy, Grey Henson proves a worthy successor to role originator Sebastian Arcelus, and tops his previous Broadway work in “Shucked” and “Mean Girls” with an altogether delightful performance. 

Philip Wm. McKinley directs at a brisk pace, and Liam Steel’s choreography is great fun. 

Gareth Owen and Peter Fitzgerald’s sound design is somewhat overamped in the current style, but the dialogue and lyrics are never distorted Tim Goodchild’s set and costume design -- lighted by Patrick Woodroffe with video design by Ian William Galloway & Mesmer Studios --  sets the festive tone, and there are several nice scenic surprises which delight. 

In its modest but winning way “Elf” more than holds its own with all the current musical offerings on Broadway, and, a rarity, actually sends the audience out humming at least one of the tunes, the earwormy “Buddy the Elf.” 

(Marquis Theatre, 210 West 46th Street; ElfOnBroadway.com; through January 4)

Photo by Evan Zimmerman for MurphyMade: (l.-r.) Grey Henson, Sean Astin